Section 6A · Materials Appendix: Acoustics
Sealant and panel specifications
Acoustic sealant
| Product | Role | Approx. cost | Spec status |
| Tremco Acoustical Sealant / Tremproof 250 | Non-hardening butyl caulk; seals poly, outlets, panel edges, every envelope penetration | $12-15 / tube | Base spec, every build |
| OSI SC175 Acoustic Sealant | Budget equivalent; marginally less flexible, fine for this application | $7-8 / tube | Approved alternate |
| Green Glue Noiseproofing Compound | Damping layer between two rigid layers; the product that actually stops transmission | ~$20 / tube, 2 tubes per 4x8 sheet | Premium option, screen wall and neighbour-facing wall only |
Spec rule: acoustic sealant is a caulking product and belongs in the base build at every penetration (pennies per unit). Green Glue is a constrained-layer damping compound and is a genuine cost add; reserve it for the Quiet Neighbour premium build. Do not substitute one for the other; they do different jobs.
Sound panels
Panels must do two jobs in a simulator room: absorb echo (NRC 0.85 or better at 2" thickness) and survive ball strikes. Decorative foam and felt panels fail the second test and are excluded from this spec.
| Option | Construction | Performance | Approx. cost / sq ft |
| Commercial impact-rated panels | Fabric-wrapped, 1"-2" mineral wool or fiberglass core, rigid ply backing (Acoustical Solutions / Residential Sound Panels golf-simulator lines) | NRC 0.85+, ball-strike rated | $15-30 |
| Shop-built panels (recommended for Golf Haven) | 2" Rockwool Safe'n'Sound over 1/2" ply backer, wrapped in acoustically transparent fabric, mounted with air gap | NRC ~0.95 at 2" with air gap, ball-strike resistant | $4-8 |
Recommendation: shop-built panels. Rockwool Safe'n'Sound is Canadian, widely stocked, and the shop-built assembly matches the board-and-batten interior aesthetic at roughly a third of commercial panel cost. It also keeps the margin in-house instead of sending it to a US panel supplier.
Placement priority
- Side walls flanking the hitting zone: full height, 2" panels. This is where mis-hits go and where transmission complaints start.
- Wall behind the player: 2" panels, mid-height band. Catches bounce-back and speaker energy.
- Ceiling over the swing arc: 2" panels between surface fixtures. Kills the slap echo off the gypsum.
- Screen wall: no acoustic panels required. The impact screen and padded backing already absorb; spend the budget on Green Glue in the wall assembly instead.
Honest performance framing (for the sales conversation)
Panels and sealant dampen echo and take the edge off transmission; they do not soundproof. True soundproofing is mass plus damping plus decoupling: double-layer walls with Green Glue, insulated door, sealed penetrations. The Quiet Neighbour package as specced gets complaint risk down enough for most backyard installs. The Green Glue premium option is for the customer with a bedroom window fifteen feet from the shed. Say this plainly; it builds more trust than overpromising, and it sets up the premium upgrade honestly.